Photo of the Week – November 4, 2011

This is an old photo of a young bird, taken with a cheap point-and-shoot digital camera in the middle of a bright sunny day.  Apologies for the photo quality.  However, you have to admit the photo has some appeal.  I particularly love those eyebrows…

Young bird along Central Platte River, Nebraska

One of the reasons for posting this photo is to get input from the birders out there.  Since I took this photo in 2005, I’ve wondered what species of bird it is.  I have a guess, which I’ll withhold until I see if there’s a consensus that forms among the replies.  Not knowing for sure has been bugging me for a long time.

The photo was taken in south-central Nebraska, about 9 miles southwest of Grand Island, along the Central Platte River.  It was in a brushy prairie with a fair number of mid-sized trees (mostly eastern red cedar and white mulberry) nearby.

Help?

26 thoughts on “Photo of the Week – November 4, 2011

  1. Terry C. Maxwell November 4, 2011 / 9:02 am

    I’m pretty sure that it’s a Black-headed Grosbeak.

    TCMaxwell

  2. Teresa November 4, 2011 / 9:07 am

    I’m sure I don’t know – but looking forward to seeing guesses – any hints on size? Very cute. He looks perfectly contented doesn’t he?

  3. Jarren November 4, 2011 / 9:22 am

    Looks a little like a Jim Henson creation

  4. Michael Scullin November 4, 2011 / 9:27 am

    Towhee.

  5. Chris M November 4, 2011 / 9:43 am

    I also say Towhee

  6. Andy R. November 4, 2011 / 10:15 am

    nice thick canocal bill…leads me to tanager, grosbeak, bunting or dickcissel; but plummage on breast and white on secondary borders infers B.H. grosbeak .

  7. Karen Hamburger November 4, 2011 / 12:18 pm

    Chris
    Ive seen baby BH Grossbeaks in the nest and that would be my best guess. Baby towhees have more slender beaks and western ones have the red eyes like their parents.
    Karen

  8. Cyndi Trail November 4, 2011 / 3:40 pm

    I deliberately did not look at your other responses to keep from being biased. I think the bird is a Rose-Breasted Grosbeak based on the body and beak type, body size, speckled back, and incipient wing bars.

  9. Candace November 4, 2011 / 5:45 pm

    I concur with the belief that this bird is a BH Grosbeak.

  10. KatiesCameraBlog November 4, 2011 / 7:22 pm

    I have no clue, but I love this photo, no matter what you took it with. :) This bird is adorable and looking right at the viewer, and that fuzzy hair. Wonderful. Great catch! :)

  11. John Solodar November 4, 2011 / 8:16 pm

    Interesting. Looking at photos of fledging and juvenile BH Grosbeaks I can see why chest color, scapular markings, and beak suggested that bird. However, I’m bothered by the tail length and color, especially the reddish-brown on the top of the tail. Also, the feet in the pictured bird are pink and on-line photos of BH Grosbeak juvenile/fledging show grey feet. The tail suggests a cuckoo, but almost everything else is wrong for one of those. It would help to have the photographer’s estimate of the size of the bird.

  12. John Solodar November 4, 2011 / 9:43 pm

    Maybe I need to retract my comment about the tail. That may be a stick that I’m looking at. However, the feet color is still bothersome.

  13. Chris Helzer November 4, 2011 / 10:20 pm

    Wow – great response! I really appreciate everyone’s input. The consensus seems to confirm my own guess – black-headed grosbeak. That was my supposition at the time of the photo, but while they’re around, they’re not a very common bird here. The beak narrowed it down, however. John S points out the color of the feet, but I would guess that is a function of my attempts to color correct for the blinding white color of the midday sun. I was still learning PhotoShop techniques in ’05 and probably overdid the color a bit. I had some other guesses and comments come through other venues too – my favorite of which was “The Andy Rooney Bird”!!

    It’s great to know that there are so many of you willing to help me figure these things out. Now I’ll have to start coming up with some other things I need identified!! Thanks again. – Chris

    P.S. Feel free to continue chiming in – especially if you disagree with the crowd and want to defend your choice!! I didn’t catch the bird, so we’ll always be able to debate…

  14. Karen Hamburger November 4, 2011 / 11:12 pm

    OK CHRIS…WHY DIDNT YOU STICK AROUND TO SEE WHO WAS FEEDING TIS BABY?????

    • Chris Helzer November 6, 2011 / 7:01 pm

      Karen – yeah, that would have been the best way to confirm, of course. My only excuse is that I was in the middle of seed harvesting at the time and felt like I should probably keep working! Now we’ll never know for sure.

  15. James McGee November 5, 2011 / 7:06 am

    Chris, this is a bird from one of my son’s favorite video games. – Angry Birds If you got closer I bet it would have flown just like it was released from a sling shot. The true identifying feature of an angry bird is it always exists with it’s co-dependant, the evil green pigs. Did you happen to see any while taking the photo? Have I confused any of the older folks yet? :)

  16. Martha November 5, 2011 / 8:11 am

    One of my birding friends said, “It’s not a robin or thrush family or it would have a speckled breast. Could be one of the King Birds.”
    Another world-traveled birding friend said, “Well, it’s really a very young bird, just out of the nest. Juvenile for sure. It kind of looks like a Black-headed Grosbeak. I think it’s a grosbeak for sure, and I’m going with Black-headed. “

  17. Mark Godfrey November 5, 2011 / 8:37 am

    Chris, From the coloration we suspect it is a Spotted Towhee, though uncommon in your area it’s range does border. Best, Mark G.

  18. Martha November 5, 2011 / 1:08 pm

    Guesses from 2 more birding friends
    Ronn says Bobolink?
    Tom says Maybe a just hatched American Robin

  19. Dan Staehr November 6, 2011 / 12:31 pm

    No birding expert here, but what about a meadowlark chick?

  20. Gary Giessow November 6, 2011 / 8:23 pm

    The first thing I noticed was the big bill. Would the shape change to the shape of a grosbeak as it matured? I guess the leg color could change with time also. The overall color and shape of the bird say grosbeak.

  21. Karine November 7, 2011 / 12:40 pm

    I used to band birds near here and it looks like an Orchard Oriole?

    • Karine November 7, 2011 / 12:42 pm

      but it does definately look like a Grosbeak too!

PLEASE COMMENT ON THIS POST!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.