Photo of the Week – August 1, 2013

I first noticed the dead ants about a year ago, when James Trager was visiting our Platte River Prairies to help us see our grassland through the eyes of ants.  As we poked around the prairie together we kept seeing ants that were stuck and dying on the flowers of two native thistle species (Flodman’s thistle – Cirsium flodmanii and Wavyleaf thistle – Cirsium undulatum).

This ant got stuck on the lower portion of this Flodman's thistle flower and eventually died there.  Helzer family prairie - south of Aurora, Nebraska.
This ant got stuck on the lower portion of this Flodman’s thistle flower and eventually died there. Helzer family prairie – south of Aurora, Nebraska.

The ants didn’t appear to be getting stuck on the numerous spines on the flowers.  Instead, they were getting caught by the flypaper-like stickiness of the lower portion of the flower as they tried to crawl up toward the nectar and pollen at the top.  While ants are definitely the most common victim of these flower traps, I’ve also seen bees, flies, and a few crab spiders get caught as well.

A small bee is among the victims on this particular flower.  The red ant on the left was still alive when I photographed it.  Flodman's thistle at the Helzer family prairie.
A small bee is among the victims on this particular flower. The red ant on the left was still alive when I photographed it. Flodman’s thistle at the Helzer family prairie.

It’s interesting to speculate whether or not ant trapping is a strategic adaptation the flowers have developed over time or just an unlucky accident for the ants.  Ants are not particularly effective pollinators, so it would make sense for thistles to evolve a strategy that helps prevent ants from “stealing” their pollen and nectar.  Since more effective pollinators such as bees and flies come to the flowers by air, stickiness of the lower portions of flowers wouldn’t affect them much (the above photo notwithstanding).  Ants have to get to the flowers by crawling, so a sticky zone between the ground and the pollen might be a very effective strategy for ant prevention.

This thistle "caught" three ants.
This thistle “caught” three ants.

The stickiness of thistle flowers is an interesting counterpoint to the extrafloral nectar produced by plant species such as sunflowers.  Sunflowers seem to produce that substance to ATTRACT ants – presumably to help ward off potential herbivores.  Thistles may be producing a substance to keep ants AWAY.  Very interesting.

Or it could just be a complete accident – which is not a very good story, and sort of sad.

(I vote for the defense barrier theory.)

8 thoughts on “Photo of the Week – August 1, 2013

  1. Matt Demmon August 1, 2013 / 12:17 pm

    Perhaps it’s not a trap to prevent ants from stealing nectar without pollinating, but a trap to prevent ants or weevils from stealing or eating the seeds. How long past flowering does the sticky quality last? Until the seeds are ripe and blow away? I noticed one of your photos is of a older brown flowerhead.

    • Chris Helzer August 1, 2013 / 5:02 pm

      It’s a good thought, Matt, and similar to James’s theory. I’m not sure how sticky the more mature heads are… I’ll have to check it out!

  2. James C. Trager August 1, 2013 / 2:15 pm

    The last photo, with the headless ant carcass, is shocking!

    My though on encountering this was that the glue is there to dissuade thistle-head attacking flies or beetles, and the ants are just incidental. Perhaps something in it that repels the thistle enemies is a bit attractive to ants. But really, all just guessing at this point.

  3. Patrick August 1, 2013 / 4:30 pm

    Interesting! I’ll have to look for this next time I see some native thistles.

  4. Judith Deaton August 1, 2013 / 11:14 pm

    What a wonderful observation. I will look much more closely at the base of thistles next year. Thanks.

  5. Matt Fisher August 2, 2013 / 9:00 am

    …or the presence of ants is a deterrent to species that might eat the flowers? Isn’t evolution fun!

PLEASE COMMENT ON THIS POST!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.