Lessons from a Yellow Tub

Last Friday night, I went to our family prairie for a last check of fence and water before cattle came in on Saturday. Shortly after the sun dropped below the horizon, I was preparing to head back home when I noticed an old yellow mineral tub that had been sitting upside down at the bottom of a small draw. I’d seen it many times before but had left it there, thinking maybe our lessee (owner of the cattle) would salvage it. This time, I figured I’d waited long enough and just picked it up. That’s when I realized how long it must have been sitting there.

The yellow tub and the results of the accidental experiment it created. For scale, the tub is 16 inches deep.

When I lifted the plastic tub and saw the mass of yellow-green grass beneath it, a rapid fire series of thoughts passed through my brain. As I processed all those thoughts, I realized there were a number of interesting ecological observations and conclusions that could be made from the situation. In other words, that empty livestock mineral feeding tub, emptied, blown by the wind, and then abandoned, had accidentally become an educational tool. Here are some of the lessons that I believe we can draw from the yellow tub of the prairie.

Let’s start with a little context. We’re managing our prairie with the ‘Open Gate Rotational Grazing System’ I described in a post a couple years ago. The prairie is split into four main pastures and a couple smaller units. Last year, the pasture containing the yellow tub was grazed intensively for most of the season, resulting in most plants being repeatedly cropped short. This year, it will rest all season, as well as most of next year.

Also, the tub landed in the former location of a big tree the cows used to cluster around for shade until I recently cut it down. That shade and consistent disturbance pushed the plant community toward brome/bluegrass dominance. As a result, most of the yellow-green grasses appear to be Kentucky bluegrass, with a little smooth brome mixed in.

A first observation is that the bluegrass and brome under the tub must have gotten an early start on the season because the tub acted as a kind of hot house this spring, providing much warmer temperatures inside the tub than out. That allowed those grasses to start growing well before most of their neighbors. Apparently, the tub was translucent enough to allow those plants to photosynthesize too, though based on the color of the grasses, they wouldn’t have minded a little more light (more on that below).

However, the disparity in height between the grasses inside and outside the tub seems too great to be explained only by warmer temperatures this spring. Instead, I believe two other factors influenced the height of those in-tub grasses. First, that tub was probably sitting there long enough to protect those grasses from last year’s grazing. The grasses outside the tub have barely managed to grown a few inches tall this spring. Those inside were touching the top (bottom?) of the tub, which is about 16 inches deep. That’s really tall for Kentucky bluegrass, even with an early start.

The impact of grazing on the grasses around the outside of the tub can be seen by looking at the other three pastures across the prairie. For example, in the pasture that didn’t get grazed at all last year, the brome is about 10 inches tall right now. Bluegrass is a little shorter, averaging around 6-8 inches. That’s way taller than the grasses in the ‘tub pasture’, which are showing stress from being repeatedly grazed last year. That grazing affected the size of their root mass and energy reserves, from which it will take them a full year or more to recover. Inside the tub, the grasses were unaffected by that grazing (just low light), so they had more energy for growth this year.

The second reason the grasses inside the tub were so small is due to a term I learned from my wife over the weekend: etiolation. Those of you who follow me on Instagram might have just caught that ‘etiolation’ is the second term I’ve learned from Kim in the last week or so. The other was ‘guttation’, which is when water droplets come out of plant leaves overnight because of a build-up of water pressure as roots continue acquiring water while transpiration has shut down.

Early morning droplets on a spiderwort leaf last week. I remarked to Kim that the drops were on spiderwort plants, but not on the other plants in the garden. That’s when she taught me about etiolation.

I digress. Etiolation, it turns out, is the name for the phenomenon that occurs when plants grow under insufficient light. Those plants are a pale color (sometimes nearly white under extreme circumstances) and tend to grow extra long and skinny in an apparent desperate attempt to reach better light. You’ve probably seen this before – I have an example in our basement right now where a bindweed plant is trying to grow from between the bricks. Anyway, I think the combination of etiolation, early warm temperatures, and grazing exclosure were probably responsible for the crazy difference in height between the grasses inside and outside of the yellow tub.

The bindweed growing in our basement. We already have enough of it to deal with in the garden – we don’t really need more. And yet, I can’t bring myself to yank it out either… It’s trying SO HARD!

Now, to really figure this out, I could get 6 or 8 identical yellow tubs and scatter them around the prairie for replication. I could put half of the tubs in areas of recent grazing and the other half where plants are recovered from grazing. If I let them sit between now and next May and then measure grass heights I should have enough statistical power to determine the relative contributions of the ‘hothouse effect’, etiolation, and grazing exclusion toward what I saw under the tub this year.

(Don’t hold your breath. I think I’ll stick with my current observations and educated guesses on this one.)

Look at how much that abandoned tub taught us! Isn’t it a good thing I waited so long to pick it up? Maybe that’s the real lesson here. I wonder what educational value I can find from the clutter in my garage. Most of that has been around much longer than the tub…

This entry was posted in Uncategorized by Chris Helzer. Bookmark the permalink.

About Chris Helzer

Chris Helzer is the Director of Science for The Nature Conservancy in Nebraska. His main role is to evaluate and capture lessons from the Conservancy’s land management and restoration work and then share those lessons with other landowners – both private and public. In addition, Chris works to raise awareness about the importance of prairies and their conservation through his writing, photography, and presentations to various groups. Chris is also the author of "The Ecology and Management of Prairies in the Central United States", published by the University of Iowa Press. He lives in Aurora, Nebraska with his wife Kim and their children.

7 thoughts on “Lessons from a Yellow Tub

  1. A great post . . . Though a slightly different perspective on the learning! The tub provided only an opportunity. The learning comes when a person is willing to think about why something happened the way it did (reflection) and also thinks about what might happen “if” (projection). Every situation provides an opportunity to learn, but the only people who do learn are those willing to take advantage of the situation. Kudos for being that type of person.

  2. From looking at my own lawn, the blue grass probably grew taller under the tub because it was not trampled in addition to effects from “etiolation.” Blue grass in lawn areas that receive a lot of traffic are stunted and sparse. In contrast, blue grass in areas with little to no foot traffic grow well especially if the area happens to be moist.

  3. Prediction: You will learn about the biology of various structure-inhabiting spiders when you get around to that garage project.

  4. Might be a good square foot (not quite meter) plot to see what unusual life you might find congregating there.


Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.