Climate Change, Carbon, and Clonal Shrubs

I’m not sure if you’ve heard about this climate change thing? Everyone’s talking about it, apparently.

Among the many impacts of climate change in Great Plains, one that has been weighing heavily on my mind is the increasing competitive advantage woody plants are gaining in grasslands because of increased drought frequency/severity and rising levels of atmospheric carbon. In Nebraska, eastern red cedar (Juniperus virgniana) has received tremendous – and well-deserved – attention in recent years as it continues to spread quickly across the state. However, while I’m concerned about cedar invasion, we have a viable strategy for dealing with it. We can kill it with fire. There is still lots of work needed to build our prescribed fire capacity in Nebraska, but there is strong momentum and I’m optimistic that we’ll eventually get on top of cedars across most of the state.

This photo shows a portion of the Niobrara Valley Preserve north of the river, where the 2012 wildfire swept through and killed huge numbers eastern red cedar and ponderosa pine trees. Under the current drought conditions, the green plants in this photo are primarily cottonwood trees, a few bur oaks, and (most prolifically) smooth sumac.

What’s getting much less attention is the growing scourge of deciduous shrubs and trees. Some of those, like Siberian elm (Ulmus pumila) and autumn olive (Elaeaganus umbellata) are nonnative invaders, but some native trees like honey locust (Gleditisia triocanthos) are also increasingly problematic. Those trees and many more can cause big problems for prairie managers on both public and private lands.

Most deciduous trees re-sprout after being top-killed by a fire or being cut down. Even multiple repetitions of those treatments won’t normally kill them, though frequent fires (every year or two over long periods of time) may eventually cause mortality and prevent new invasions. In most cases, once they’ve established themselves, those trees have to be dealt with one-by-one and treated with herbicide to kill them for good. That’s a tremendous challenge, especially when those trees become abundant.

However, while really scary, even the invasion of those trees isn’t the threat I worry about most. I’m much more concerned about the clonal deciduous shrubs – most of them native species – that are incrementally blanketing and smothering grasslands. These include species such as smooth sumac (Rhus glabra), dogwoods (Cornus sp.), and even wild plum (Prunus americana), among many others.

Because they grow in large colonies, connected belowground by rhizomes, clonal shrubs invade as massive cooperative armies, rather than as scattered individuals. This strategy gives them lots of advantages, including an ability to create ever-expanding canopies of leaves that shade out competition. Eventually, that shading-out process can fireproof those clones as grasses beneath the canopy become so sparse that fires won’t carry through them.

Here’s a closer shot of sumac clones and skeletons of dead cedar trees at the Niobrara Valley Preserve, surrounded by dormant prairie vegetation this week. This image, and others below, provides a frightening illustration of how drought conditions can help sumac and other clonal shrubs gain additional advantages over other prairie plants.

Increasing carbon dioxide in the atmosphere gives these clonal shrubs a leg up on many prairie plants. So does the increasing frequency and severity of droughts. While most prairie plants have deep roots, you may remember an earlier blog post that shared recent research showing that only shrubs and trees seem to be pulling water from deep in the soil, even during droughts. Many herbaceous (non-woody) prairie plants go dormant or dramatically slow their growth when the soil dries up. Shrubs like smooth sumac and dogwood just keep plugging away, drawing moisture from further down in the ground.

This week, while spending some time at our Niobrara Valley Preserve, I took some photos that help illustrate the varying impacts of drought on prairie vegetation. The Niobrara Valley Preserve and the surrounding area have received less rainfall this year than during the 2012 drought. The University of Nebraska-Lincoln’s drought monitor shows the area around the Preserve as being under severe drought conditions, but because of local rainfall amounts and distribution, it’s even worse than that across most of the property. As a result, much of the prairie is brown and crispy.

…except for clonal shrubs like smooth sumac and wild plum.

Smooth sumac stands out as green vegetation against a backdrop of drought-stricken Sandhills prairie.
These smooth sumac plants look just as vibrant as always while most of the surrounding plants are either dormant or showing other signs of drought stress.

In the midst of that matrix of dried and dormant prairie vegetation, clonal deciduous shrubs are thriving. Those shrubs look perfectly healthy and happy while most other plants have shut down for the year. It doesn’t take a prairie ecologist to recognize what happens if some plants can keep growing and spreading while their competition is sidelined. If summer droughts continue to become more common, sumac, plum, and other clonal shrubs are going to be more and more difficult to deal with.

Dealing with clonal shrubs is a huge challenge, especially when those clones get big. It’s not hard to kill an individual sumac stem. You can cut it off at the ground and paint the stump with herbicide. The real issue comes when you’re facing tens of thousands of those stems. You can broadcast herbicide across a clone, but that will also kill many of the plants beneath. That, of course, is really bad for the productivity and health of the prairie we’re trying to save.

Scientists and landowners in places like the Flint Hills of Kansas or in many eastern tallgrass prairies have shown that burning annually or every other year can keep these clonal shrubs at bay. That, however, comes with its own consequences, including significant impacts to invertebrates and other animals. In addition, at least in the Great Plains, frequent fire can favor grass dominance and reduce plant diversity. It also greatly reduces the options available for grazing systems when you have to leave behind enough grass each year to carry next year’s fire.

More significantly, frequent fire is hard to envision as a feasible option to be applied across the entire Great Plains. Apart from the actual logistics involved in burning privately-owned grasslands at that scale, the smoke produced by those fires would be hugely problematic. Much of the Flint Hills landscape of Kansas is annually burned, and in addition to the aforementioned consequences to wildlife and plant diversity, that annual burning is causing significant human health concerns from smoke concentrations – even in neighboring states.

The Flint Hills is about 4 million acres in size and only about half of that is burned each year. Now imagine the impacts from smoke produced by annual fires across the Nebraska Sandhills (12 million acres) or the majority of all Nebraska’s grasslands (23 million acres). Even if spread across the year, that’s a tremendous amount of smoke, especially when multiplied across other grassland-heavy states like the Dakotas, Kansas, Oklahoma, and others.

Fire will probably be part of the answer, but we’re going to need more than just a significant increase in our prescribed fire work. Goats are being used in some places, and might be another partial answer in certain situations, but goats don’t kill shrubs, they just knock them back. They also eat lots of other plants besides just shrubs, so need careful management to prevent negative impacts to plant diversity. Goats also present a number of difficulties when it comes to managing them – especially in terms of keeping them in place and/or alive.

The point of all this griping is that we need to get serious about finding more and better ways to address the spread of clonal shrubs in the Great Plains. We already have a significant problem in some places – especially in the eastern portions of the Plains and in other specific locations (like the Middle Niobrara River Valley) where shrub invasions have been growing unchecked for a long time. If we don’t find ways to slow it now, the problem is going to overwhelm us.

We waited too long to start dealing with eastern red cedars and now we’re really racing to try to save places like Nebraska from being completely overtaken (some landscapes in the southern Plains are likely past the point of saving). That’s happening despite the fact that we’ve known for a very long time how to deal with cedars (fire). Now we’re facing another wave of invasions that we don’t yet know how to fight. Let’s not wait until our boats are underwater before we start bailing.

Ok, if you’ve made it this far and are feeling down, here are a few photos that might cheer you up just a little. While much of the prairie at the Niobrara Valley Preserve was dormant or heavily wilted this week, there were some plant species apart from sumac and plum that were still doing well. I spent a lot of time trying to document which species still looked happy, despite that drought, and there were quite a few – mostly wildflowers and forb-like shrubs.

One plant that seems to be doing well despite the dry soils is hairy goldaster (Heterotheca villosa).
Lead plant (Amorpha canescens) is also thriving, despite the dry conditions.
Many annual plants like this prickly poppy (Argemone polyanthemos) and plains sunflower (Helianthus petiolaris) seem to be weathering the drought very well.
Prairie clovers, including white prairie clover (Dalea candida), purple prairie clover (Dalea purpurea) and the species shown here, silky prairie clover (Dalea villosa) are all looking good.

Below is a partial list of plants that were still green and vibrant in the drought-stricken prairies of the Niobrara Valley Preserve this year. I’d love to partner with someone who has the interest and capacity to look at the strategies these plants are using to weather dry conditions. Are these outliers in terms of the deep-roots-to-pull-water conundrum? Or do they have other strategies that allow them to be more efficient with water or effective in dealing with dry soils? So many fun things to think about.

Some of the still-green plants in the droughty Sandhills prairie this week:

Missouri goldenrod (Solidago missouriensis)

Prairie clovers (Dalea purpurea, D. candida, D. villosa)

Cudweed sagewort (Artemisia ludoviciana)

Hairy puccoon (Lithospermum caroliniense)

Lead plant (Amorpha canescens)

Scaly blazing star (Liatris squarrosa)

Hairy goldaster (Heterotheca villosa)

Green sage (Artemisia campestre)

Sand milkweed (Asclepias arenaria)


One of the nice things about the prairie plants that are still actively growing and flowering is the habitat they provide for animals that need to keep eating and living during drought conditions. Despite the severe drought, there is still a lot of animal activity in the prairies at the Niobrara Valley Preserve. I caught a little evidence of that with my camera this week, but not enough to be representative of the full spectrum of activity and sound going on around me while I was there.

I’ll end this with some optimism. Despite my real and serious worries about clonal shrub invasion and the facilitation of that by climate change, prairies are still very resilient. That resilience gives me a lot of hope for their future and gives us a lot to work with as we struggle to manage and restore them. Prairies have been through a lot and they’ll survive a lot more if we can continue to give them some help.

This western bush cicada (Megatibicen tremulus) was glad there are still some green plants around to feed on, including this plains sunflower.
This bee (and a grasshopper behind it) were also glad to have some green and flowering plants to feed on.

Photos of the Week – August 5, 2022

The prairies around here are approaching peak color as big-blossomed late summer wildflowers prepare to open. In the meantime, the last couple weeks have provided plenty of fodder for my camera during some early morning wandering sessions. Without a lot of explanation or interpretation, here are some of the photo highlights from my last two weeks.

If you can, get out there and do your own exploration!

Freshly molted robber fly at The Nature Conservancy’s Niobrara Valley Preserve. Nikon 105mm macro lens with Raynox 250 macro attachment. ISO 320, f/16, 1/160 sec.
Prairie cordgrass and sedge meadow at sunrise. The Nature Conservancy’s Platte River Prairies. Nikon 18-300mm lens @122mm. ISO 500, f/16, 1/1600.
Dragonfly in the early morning prairie. The Nature Conservancy’s Platte River Prairies. Nikon 10.5mm fisheye lens. ISO 400, f/22, 1/160 sec.
Striped lynx spider (Oxyopes salticus). The Nature Conservancy’s Platte River Prairies. Nikon 105mm macro lens. ISO 320, f/11, 1/250 sec.
Delaware skipper. Lincoln Creek Prairie, Aurora, Nebraska. Nikon 105mm macro lens with Raynox 250 macro attachment. ISO 500, f/13, 1/125 sec.
Rope dodder (Cuscuta glomerata), a native parasitic plant feeding on Maximilian sunflower (Helianthus maximiliani). The Nature Conservancy’s Platte River Prairies. Nikon 10.5mm fisheye lens. ISO 500, f/22, 1/100 sec.
Wild bergamot (Monarda fistulosa). Lincoln Creek Prairie, Aurora, Nebraska. Nikon 105mm macro lens. ISO 500, f/18, 1/60 sec.
Two-lined spittlebug (Prosapia bicincta). Lincoln Creek Prairie in Aurora, Nebraska. Nikon 105mm macro lens. ISO 640, f/11, 1/60 sec.
Two-lined spittlebug (Prosapia bicincta). Lincoln Creek Prairie, Aurora, Nebraska. Nikon 105mm macro lens with Raynox 250 macro attachment. ISO 640, f/18, 1/80 sec.
Aphids on stiff sunflower (Helianthus pauciflorus). Nikon 105mm macro lens. ISO 320, f/16, 1/100 sec.
Cows at sunrise in recently-planted prairie. The Nature Conservancy’s Platte River Prairies. Tokina 11-20mm lens @20mm. ISO 320, f/14, 1/125 sec.
Calves on restored prairie with a windmill. Nikon 105mm macro lens. ISO 500, f/16, 1/125 sec.
Rocky mountain bee plant (Cleome serrulata). The Nature Conservancy’s Platte River Prairies, Nebraska. Nikon 105mm macro lens. ISO 500, f/10, 1/400 sec.
Sweat bee climbing an anther to feed on Rocky Mountain bee plant pollen. Nikon 105mm macro lens. ISO 500, f/10, 1/400 sec.
Long-horned bees (Melissodes sp) in their overnight roost inside a prairie gentian flower (Eustoma grandiflorum). Nikon 105mm macro lens. ISO 500, f/16, 1/80 sec.
Metallic green sweat bee in its overnight roost in a prairie gentian flower (Eustoma grandiflorum). Nikon 105mm macro lens. ISO 500, f/16, 1/60 sec.