Post-Grazing Party: Part 3 – Helzer Family Prairie

As I said back in early May, I’m spending a lot of my photography time in three 80×80-foot plots this summer. Each plot in part of a prairie that was grazed intensively most or all of last year. I’m hoping to highlight why I enjoy exploring places where the growth of normally-dominant plants (especially grasses) is temporarily suppressed from last year’s grazing.

Space and opportunities are opened for other plant species to flourish for a year or so until those dominant species hit full strength again. Generally, I see all the perennial plants I’m used to seeing, but they’re joined (temporarily) by a flush of short-lived plants as well.

In addition, the habitat structure is unique and interesting – especially as the season progresses. It often resembles a kind of miniature savanna, with wildflowers instead of trees towering over short grasses. It’s a habitat type preferred by many invertebrate and vertebrate wildlife species.

Pussytoes (Antennaria neglecta) went to seed in mid May at our family prairie. This is a long-lived rhizomatous plant that definitely enjoys the short habitat structure created by grazing.

Today’s post features the 80×80 plot at my family prairie, where I’m experimenting with the open gate rotational grazing. This is basically a big photo dump from about the last month or so. To make up for the large number of photos, I’ve kept the text to a minimum, but have hopefully included enough to give you some context. There’s a lot happening, and every visit I’ve made has resulted in some terrific photos.

Pussytoes and sunset.

Early in the season, the vegetation was pretty uniformly short. Pussytoes, only 6 to 8 inches tall, towered over the surrounding landscape. By mid-June, though, things have changed, with opportunistic wildflowers like yarrow and daisy fleabane growing more than two feet tall and providing an interesting mix of tall and short vegetation structure. That means animals have lots of choices between open, sunny areas and cool, shady cover.

Yarrow (with fleabane in the background) growing tall, surrounded by short grasses.
Mid-June in the part of our family prairie that was grazed intensively all last season. The orange flags mark the corners of my 80×80 foot plot.

The 80×80 foot plot at our family prairie is located on a slope I believe to be remnant (never plowed) prairie. There have been a lot of wildflower species blooming, and a lot more are getting ready. Many are native, but a few aren’t – though none are invasive or problematic.

Shell-leaf penstemon (Penstemon grandiflorus) is a species I’ve seeded into the prairie in recent years (from seed harvested nearby).
False gromwell, aka marbleseed (Onosmodium molle).
The flowers of false gromwell are closed at the tip, restricting pollinators to those strong enough to force their way inside and/or those with long tongues.
A lot of daisy fleabane (Erigeron strigosus) germinated last year during the grazing and is blooming happily this year before dying at the end of this season.

I’ve paid attention to how much fruit has been produced by ground plum in places that were grazed and ungrazed last year. The grazed areas, including my plot, have way more fruits on the plants than I see in the ungrazed sites. I wonder if that’s because they bloomed more prolifically, were pollinated more, or something else (or, likely, a combination of factors). Either way, it’s a stark difference.

Ground plum, aka buffalo pea (Astragalus crassicarpus) fruits.
Silver-leaf scurfpea (Pediomelum argophyllum) is a long-lived perennial that seems unaffected by grazing.
Peppergrass (Lepidium densiflorum) is a neat little annual that is doing well with the abundant light and low grass competition.
Goatsbeard, aka salsify (Tragopogon dubius) is a non-native wildflower I enjoy. It’s short-lived and profits from less competitive grasses.
The non-native legume black medic (Medicago lupulina) is one of the big winners in all three of my 80×80 foot plots this year. Next year, it will be drastically less abundant as grasses recover their vigor.
The invasive smooth brome (Bromus inermis) is found in pretty much every Nebraska prairie these days, but while it bloomed in my 80×80 plot, its minimal vegetative production showed how little competition it was able to provide in the community this spring.

The abundance of invertebrates is one of my favorite aspects of these post-grazing areas. They seem to be drawn to the combination of sun and shade in close proximity, which allows them to easily thermoregulate. A bonanza of wildflowers also draws a lot of pollinators, and that’ll become even more apparent over the next month or two as prairie clover (a particular favorite of bees) starts blooming.

Katydid nymph.
Grasshopper.
A blister beetle (Epicauta sp.)

I’ve photographed three ladybird beetles (ladybugs) in the plot so far this year, including the non-native seven-spotted ladybird and two native species.

Seven-spotted ladybird beetle (non-native)
Convergent ladybird beetle (native) on daisy fleabane, with an aphid, its favorite prey, shown at the top of the photo.
Parenthesis ladybird beetle (native).
Tiny beetle on stiff goldenrod (Oligoneuron rigida).
Reakirt’s blue butterfly.
There have been lots of wolf spiders running around on the bare soil.

There’s lots of patchy bare ground in the post-grazing portion of our prairie this year. That makes for great habitat for many invertebrates. It should also be great for ground-nesting bees. The other day, I saw what I thought was probably the entrance to a small bee’s nest and hung around to see if I could get a photo of the bee coming or going. I did manage to spot and photograph the resident, but it turned out not to be a bee. Instead, it was the larva of a tiger beetle – a group of species whose larva and adult stages both enjoy hunting in areas of bare ground.

Tiger beetle larva entrance.
Tiger beetle larva ready to hunt. If you click on the photo to get a bigger/clearer version you can get a much better view of its face.

I mentioned daisy fleabane earlier. It’s definitely one of the plant species that has benefitted greatly from last year’s grazing. While many people consider it “weedy” because it’s a biennial, it’s attractive and I’ve enjoyed watching all the diversity and activity taking place on it this spring.

Daisy fleabane (Erigeron strigosus)
A bug (showing its long mouthpart) hiding behind a flower.
A tiny bug (Lygus lineolaris?) feeding on daisy fleabane.
A fly infected by the Entomopthora muscae fungus. Read more here: https://prairieecologist.com/2024/06/25/early-summer-natural-history-stories/
Fly feeding on yarrow.

I’ll finish with a barrage of crab spider photos from this site. It’s been a great year for crab spiders at many of the prairies I’ve visited, but they seem particularly abundant here. They’re hanging around on lots of different flowers, hunting the many invertebrates coming to visit those blossoms.

Crab spiderling on pussytoes.
Crab spider on yarrow.
Crab spider on daisy fleabane.
Crab spider on silver-leaf scurfpea.
Crab spider on daisy fleabane.
Crab spider on daisy fleabane with captured fly.
Crab spider (male) on daisy fleabane with a setting sun behind it.

The Penstemon Lumberjack Mystery

Shell-leaf penstemon in a restored grassland at the Platte River Prairies back in 2021.

One of my favorite wildflowers is the spectacular shell-leaf penstemon (Penstemon grandiflorus). It’s one of the showiest of the opportunistic wildflowers in our prairies. Shell-leaf penstemon thrives under heavy grazing, in sandy and/or low-productivity soils, or other places where most other plants struggle. Every year, as the month of May progresses, I watch closely for the first blooms so I can get out and photograph them.

Which is why it really ticks me off that an unknown entity chops a bunch of them down every year. I don’t know who’s doing it, I don’t know why they’re doing it, and it’s incredibly frustrating. I’m sorry to lose the flowers, but my biggest resentment is that I can’t explain what’s happening.

What’s particularly confusing is that whomever cuts the top of these plants off with their teeth doesn’t appear to then eat anything it removes. The tops of the plants are just left lying around.

It’s almost as if someone is annoyed by the excessive height of the plants and has a compulsion to hack them down and keep them short. Or maybe they just hate beautiful flowers. But if that’s the case, there are plenty of other gorgeous wildflowers in the prairie they could attack and I’ve never seen this “cut and leave it lie” behavior with any other plant species in our prairies.

Having said that, I guess prairie dogs do chop plants down around their towns, but we don’t have prairie dogs at the Platte River Prairies. Unless they’re really, really sneaky prairie dogs. I’m not dismissing any possibilities right now, but that one feels pretty far-fetched.

What is happening? Why would some animal nip the top off a penstemon plant and then just leave it there??

My top candidates are black-tailed jackrabbits, but thirteen-lined ground squirrels are high on that list, too. It also feels like the kind of thing a cranky, vindictive white-tailed deer might do, but the sharp angled cut feels more like rabbit or rodent. Google says pocket gophers can reduce the size of penstemon populations, but they’re underground foragers, so they don’t seem likely.

To be clear, I don’t begrudge any animal its search for food. By all means, eat all the plants you want to eat! In fact, it makes me feel good to know that our prairies and stewardship work are providing sustenance for wildlife.

But this looks like wanton destruction, not foraging. Apart from disliking the height or beauty of the plant, the only other explanation I can come up with is that something wants access to the liquid inside the stem. Are rabbits cutting the tops off the plants and then sipping xylem and/or phloem out of the stems like a kid with a soda straw?

Now that I’ve got that visual in my head, if that’s what’s going on, what I’m most mad about is that I’ve not gotten to watch it happen. It sounds adorable.

You can see the tops of the plants lying next to the bases they were nipped off of.
The sharp angled cuts look like what I’d expect from a rabbit or ground squirrel.

I’m hoping those of you who read this will have some helpful information for me. Have you seen this near you? Have you seen it with other plants besides shell-leaf penstemon? Any idea who would do it, or why? Do you have friends who might know? Acquaintances?

I don’t want to pressure you, but honestly, if we can’t use this blog’s reach and influence to solve a simple mystery like this, why am I wasting my time with it? I could do other things with my life. For example, I could…

Hm. Ok, I retract that threat.

But still, someone out there has to have an explanation, right? I’ve been seeing this phenomenon for years, so it’s not an isolated incident. I’m also pretty sure it’s not just one ill-tempered individual jackrabbit with a bad attitude about penstemon. As far as I know, jackrabbits don’t usually live longer than five years and I’ve been watching this for more than a decade.

Thanks in advance for your help. Any reporting will be appreciated. If you’ve seen something similar, tell me both where you saw it and any relevant details – plant species, topography, soil type, local rodent/lagomorph species, most popular local sports team, etc. We don’t know what will constitute key information, so the more the better. If you yourself don’t have anything to report, please pass this post on to others who might know something. Let’s figure this out!