I came across a copy of one of my all-time favorite research articles the other day. The paper tells a great story about the kinds of complex interactions that occur between the biotic and abiotic components of an ecosystem, including feedback loops and ecological hierarchies. But more importantly, it’s a story about a guy who dumps bison urine on the prairie to see what happens.
The research paper, written by Ernie Steinauer and Scott Collins was actually a report from the second of two projects they conducted on bison urine impacts at the Konza Prairie Biological Station in Kansas. Both projects were interesting, but I like the second one best because it focused on how bison urine can affect the prairie community at multiple scales.
Bison and cattle urine creates patches of high nitrogen concentration in the soil. You can identify those patches in a pasture because they look like dinner plate-sized areas of extra dark green grass that, if left ungrazed, are taller than the surrounding vegetation. Previous studies had shown that livestock urine increased the aboveground production of plants and altered plant species composition. Other researchers had also found that herbivores preferentially graze urine-treated areas because of increased plant production and higher N concentration in leaves. Steinauer and Collins fully expected to see the same patterns, but they also wanted to see whether or not those urine patches acted as initiation points for grazing lawns.
If you were to walk around a pasture being grazed at a moderate stocking rate, you’d see patches of uniformly short vegetation (often bathtub to bathroom-sized or so) surrounded by a matrix of somewhat taller vegetation. Those short-cropped areas are called “grazing lawns”, and often consist of a single species of grass such as smooth brome (Bromus inermis) or big bluestem (Andropogon gerardii) that is particularly favored by grazers. Grazing lawns are a result of livestock repeatedly feeding from the same plants all season long while ignoring others. They do this because the regrowth from plants that have already been grazed tends to be more nutritious than more mature leaves of plants that haven’t.
In their study, Steinauer and Collins wanted to see whether small deposits of bison urine would stimulate much larger grazing lawns around them. If so, a small fertilization event by a bison would actually lead to a much larger disturbance to the prairie community. In order to test their idea, they first needed some bison urine. (How would you like to be handed that task?) Fortunately, the great wealth of scientific literature includes a publication from 1978 that has a recipe for simulated bison urine. Don’t you love science? Steinauer and Collins helpfully reprinted the recipe in their research paper so the rest of us could join in the fun.
(“…Excuse me, I’d like to buy a big batch of urea so I can mix me up some artificial bison urine. Yes, I can wait a moment. Oh, hello officer, where’d you come from? You’d like me to step that way? Sure. Hey! Where are we going??”)
I’ve included links to both bison urine research papers by Steinauer and Collins at the bottom of this post, but in summary, they confirmed that bison preferentially grazed patches treated with urine (65% of urine-treated plots were grazed, compared to only 18% of untreated plots). However, the bigger story is that those urine patches also acted as initiation points for larger grazing lawns. In fact, many fewer untreated plots would have been grazed if they hadn’t been enveloped by grazing lawns that started in nearby treated plots.
What do we learn from this? We learn that when a bison (or cow) decides to relieve itself in a particular place, it’s very likely starting a cascade of impacts…
- Urine fertilization increases the growth rate and nitrogen content of the plants in a small area.
- Those particularly nutritious plants attract a hungry bison, which after devouring the vegetation in that little spot, keeps its head down and eats a lot more of the same plants in the vicinity.
- The competitive balance between the plant species within the grazing lawn temporarily changes as grazed grasses lose root mass, opening up space for other plants that couldn’t otherwise compete with them.
- Grazing lawns improves habitat for a number of wildlife species, including insects and reptiles, that depend upon the availability of open sunny areas adjacent to taller shady vegetation.
While Steinauer and Collins studied changes in plant composition within their urine patches, they only followed those plants for a single season, and found some conflicting results between their two studies. Some of those may have come from the fact that their two studies took place on somewhat different soil types. However, my own grazing research has shown that many of the effects of grazing are most evident in the year following the grazing event, after colonizing plants have had time to move into areas left open by weakened grasses. It would have been very interesting to have followed the urine patches through several seasons to see how plant composition changed over that time period.
I’ve never met Ernie Steinauer but I bet I’d like him. I say this because in addition to being crazy enough to mix up and dump bison urine on the prairie just to see what happened, Ernie also kept track of other interesting things that happened within his urine-treated patches. One thing he noticed was that insect herbivory – especially on switchgrass (Panicum virgatum) – seemed to be influenced by urine treatments as well. Now there’s the beginning to a great follow up project for someone! After you try it, let me know what you find.
Here are the links to the two articles.
Hmm, grass patch draws more bison, more bison urinate in that area due to increased grazing pressure in that spot, area grows larger. This could lead to whole, open meadows in one area.
Yep. But that’s where other forces can come in to re-set the whole system. Fire, for example, can shift the grazing pressure into one area, allowing other areas to rest (assuming stocking rate isn’t excessive).
Also, we think (though it’s not been tracked well) a grazing lawn eventually “runs out of steam” as the favored grasses lose the energy to keep regrowing. Grazers then shift away from from that lawn to another until the grasses recover their vigor.
AND… from a structural standpoint there is still at least some heterogeneity even when there are a lot of grazing lawns around because there are plants – even grasses like switchgrass – that are not as palatable as others, so they stay taller and keep everything from being uniformly short. Again, assuming stocking rate is’t excessive…
And I thought cowpea was a plant….and the sequel to the above post, Whereever the chips may fall….bison chips that is! :)
I have nothing to add to this discussion!
Great information as always; and about topics, well, not found just any old place. The pun in the subject line is a classic. Keep writing.
I have no pun to add but I have noticed some thing in my back yard….where the dog pees…and poops , the grass(crabgrass) grow much more agressively. AND the rabits that graze my yard (in herds) prefer this prolific growth to even the most tender of garden yummies. Now I have my own reserch to do!
COOL!! Thanks Chris!
Chris, A landscape scale example is the migration routes of Caribou. The nitrogen enriched trails used by Caribou are visible using infra-red cameras.
Thanks Chris, I love your story of how ridiculous science experiments can sometimes seem. My favorite weird moment came when I conducted a seed burial experiment. I wanted to bury seeds for set periods and then dig them up again so we could find out how long seeds stayed viable in the soil. So I could find them again many months later, I made little envelopes out of curtain material, and put the seeds in these, and then buried the envelopes.
The weird bit was going to the curtain shop and being asked, what color did I want, what pattern, length, weave, etc, etc. When I told the saleswoman that it didn’t matter as I was going to cut it all up into little squares and then bury it in a paddock, she looked at me as though I was an axe murderer. I’m sure every field scientist and restorationist has a similar story to tell! Best wishes Ian
Thanks Chris! I should have known about this article…and now I do. I’ve wondered since beginning research at Konza why so many of the grazing lawns are on exposed hilltops and ridges at Konza and all along the fence on the south side of the bison area (also up high). When it is hot, that’s where the bison seem to hang out. Maybe they urinate and then graze there because of their temperature-related behaviors.
I like this concept more than the chicken and the egg. What came first? Deposition patch or grazing?