Smooth Sumac Suppression

You might recall a couple posts back in the summer of 2025 about woody encroachment in prairies. In the first, I talked about how it is becoming increasingly difficult to prevent woody encroachment in many prairie landscapes. Within those landscapes, we need to start learning how to manage shrubbier grasslands for biodiversity and productivity. In the second post, I discussed a couple small trials we were conducting to examine various stewardship approaches to suppressing the height and density of shrubs (one of which is the subject of today’s post).

Feel free to go back and read those posts if you like. They’re reasonably well-written, if I do say so myself. To save you time, though, the quick summary of the first is that increased carbon dioxide in the atmosphere is making woody plants much more competitive these days. That, combined with altered fire regimes, changes in native browsers, and other factors, means many prairies are getting shrubbier.

Where we can maintain open prairies with minimal woody cover, we should do that. However, if you’re managing a prairie that already has a lot of shrubs or trees, or if your prairie is surrounded by a landscape full of woody plants, it might be time for a different approach.

Your intrepid author, surrounded by smooth sumac taller than himself. Not all woody encroachment has to look like this. I, apparently, do.

Trying to eradicate big patches of shrubs from prairies, even if it’s possible (and it probably isn’t), is likely to cause losses in plant diversity and other negative impacts. Instead, what if we figure out how to mitigate some of the downsides of those shrubs and try to preserve diverse, if woodier, prairies? Again, I’m greatly simplifying this whole topic, so if this seems illogical or confusing, please go back and read those earlier posts.

We’ve been experimenting with various approaches toward managing the habitat structure of shrubby prairies. Today, I’m sharing some results of early trials with smooth sumac. I’ll report soon on some work we’re doing with roughleaf dogwood and western snowberry.

You can click on graphs and photos to see larger versions of them. If you’re reading this in an email, you might have to first click on the title of the post to open it online.

Back in 2023, we set up some trial plots at the Niobrara Valley Preserve to test the basic idea that multiple treatments in a growing season would have longer lasting effects than a single treatment. Others have seen that combining treatments leads to better results, so we were trying to build on those efforts. We tested combinations of three treatments – mowing, fire, and an herbicide called AIM, which is a contact herbicide that basically desiccates the foliage of broadleaf plants and shrubs. All these plots were treated in 2023 only. I went back to measure the results three years later in late 2026.

I was particularly interested in the herbicide because unlike most herbicides used for shrub control, this one won’t kill either the shrubs or any surrounding perennial wildflowers. The hope was that it would act similarly to a fire. The first thing we learned is that it doesn’t do very much to full-size sumac plants. The herbicide spray didn’t penetrate well into the canopy and just burned off some of the top leaves. However, it worked much better as a second treatment on the regrowth of mowed stems. As a result, we abandoned the plots where we sprayed AIM as a first treatment.

Through a series of intentional and unintentional circumstances, we ended up with three different small experiments (see above). Each has very little replication, so please remember that when you look at the results. THESE ARE VERY PRELIMINARY TESTS. We were just looking for hints of patterns to pursue more rigorously in the future.

In 2026, I went back to the plots and measured the height of the sumac – three years after our treatments. I was surprised and pleased with how durable the impacts had been. I wish I’d measured changes in stem density too, especially because I saw a fair number of top-killed stems in the plots, but I didn’t, and we’ll all have to live with that.

You can see the graphs above and photos below, showing the results of experiment #1. Three full field seasons after treatment, sumac stems that were either mowed twice or mowed and sprayed with AIM were still about half as tall as untreated stems. It’s a pretty striking difference.

The second experiment looked at plots that were mowed in either June or August and then burned in late November of the same year. This took place on a site with a drier soil type (I think, based on aboveground observation only) than the first. As a result, the sumac grows shorter and less densely here than in the other nearby sites.

I was surprised that both the June and August mowing treatments seemed to significantly reduce sumac height (even three years after treatment!) when combined with a November fire. The stems that were burned without being mowed first seemed to rebound to their full height within two years (based on visual comparison to nearby patches the fire missed). The stems that were mowed first were still about half that height after three full field seasons.

In experiment #3, we looked at the cumulative effects of three treatments, including mowing in June, mowing or AIM herbicide in August, and then a late November burn later that year. The treatment plots were again very different than the untreated plots. In this experiment, the Mow+AIM herbicide results looked a little less impressive than the Mow+Mow results, but remember that this was based on only TWO replications, so take those results with a grain of salt. However, even the Mow+AIM plots were still much shorter than the plots that weren’t treated at all.

We will be following up on this work in the coming years, hopefully with some larger treatment areas. I’m particularly intrigued by two things. First, adding a dormant season burn following summer mowing had a bigger impact than I’d expected. At a site like the Niobrara Valley Preserve where we have thousands of acres of sumac-encroached grassland, it’s not feasible to mow much of that twice in the same season. But if we can mow some of it before or after a burn and strongly amplify the effects of the burn, that might be worth trying.

Second, the AIM herbicide results were promising enough to warrant more testing. It is an herbicide treatment that shouldn’t decrease plant diversity around or beneath treated shrubs. It can also be used on topography that is too steep or rough to be mowed. That means we might be able to combine it with burning and (as above) greatly increase the effectiveness of that fire on shrub suppression.

All of this is great, of course, and provides me with more optimism that we can manage shrubby prairies in ways that sustain plant diversity, offer good habitat for most prairie wildlife species, and prevent big losses in livestock productivity. The simultaneous challenge, though, is to figure out what to aim for with our management. We don’t know much about how various wildlife species respond to different heights and densities of shrubs, or at what height/density shrubs start decreasing plant diversity or productivity beneath them. We’ll be trying to answer some of those questions in the coming years as well. Hopefully, some of you will be doing the same!

Habitat Heterogeneity in One Photo

I was featured on a podcast episode that came out today. I’ve enjoyed being a guest on quite a few podcasts, but I think this one might have produced the best synthesis of many of my thoughts on prairie management. If you’re interested in listening to it, check out the Wild Ag Podcast on your favorite app or click here.

A variety of habitat conditions across one swath of grassland at The Nature Conservancy’s Platte River Prairies in Nebraska back in 2023. Click on the photo if you want to see a bigger version.

Speaking of prairie management, as I was preparing a presentation on the topic last week, I came across an aerial photo I’d taken a couple years ago at our Platte River Prairies. The image does a great job of illustrating what habitat heterogeneity can look like across one management unit.

Variation in available habitat conditions (habitat heterogeneity) can be created by many factors. Some of those factors are unrelated to our actions as land managers. Topography, soil texture, and soil moisture, for example, all have big influences on what plant species can grow in a particular place. The same conditions can also drive the height and density of plants – high/dry/south facing slopes will have much shorter/sparser vegetation than low-lying/moist valleys, for example.

In the photo shown above, that influence can be seen in at least a couple ways. First, in the foreground of the photo, there are yellow stripes created by concentrations of blooming perennial sunflowers and goldenrods. Those plants are spread throughout the site, but are most lush and abundantly flowering in soils laid down by old river channels hundreds/thousands of years ago when this part of the prairie was part of the active Platte River.

Similarly, in the top part of the photo, you can see a broad slough that looks slightly darker than the surrounding vegetation. That slough is also an old river channel and has not only different soils, but is also lower in elevation and closer to groundwater, which helps determine both the plant species growing there and the height and vigor of those plants.

The management history of this site also plays a big role in the available habitat today. The top portion of the photo is unplowed (remnant) prairie, though it had some years of chronic overgrazing that decreased its plant diversity before The Nature Conservancy acquired it. We’ve replenished some of that lost plant diversity by overseeding missing species, but the plant community is still not what it was. On the other hand, it does have a very strong native sedge community and a pretty nice set of early season wildflowers that aren’t in the portion of prairie shown at the bottom of the photo.

That area shown in the lower portion of the photo was in row crops for years before being planted (not by us) back to grassland with a few wildflower species. Since then, it has increased in plant diversity, but no botanist would mistake it for an unplowed remnant prairie. It provides excellent habitat for many animal species, but has obvious differences from the adjacent remnant site.

Finally, the most dramatic variation in vegetation structure at the time this photo was taken was driven by recent management actions taken by Platte River Prairies manager Cody Miller and others. The entire prairie shown in the photo had cattle on it during the year of the photo (and in prior years). However, the grazing pressure across the site was very uneven, driven by prescribed burning.

In 2023, a spring fire was conducted in the area shown in the foreground, and a late July burn took place near the top right of the photo. When the 2023 growing season started, cattle focused most of their grazing in the recent spring burn, keeping that vegetation short and allowing plants elsewhere to grow tall. After the smaller August burn took place, cattle shifted some of their grazing there, reducing grazing pressure on the spring burn – which is partly why the sunflowers are blooming so abundantly. If you’re interested, you can read more about that summer fire and see more photos of it here and here.

Meanwhile, most of the remainder of the site had lots of tall vegetation and relatively thick thatch (accumulated dry vegetation from previous years’ growth) because it hadn’t been burned recently and had recovered from previous grazing bouts.

This mid-September photo shows part of the remnant prairie, with unburned grassland on the left and the summer burn on the right. The two areas provide very different habitat conditions for plants and animals, each of which is valuable.

As a whole, this management unit (roughly 500 acres, with more prairie across the creek to the north – out of frame to the right) provided a wide variety of habitat conditions for the plants and animals living in it back in 2023. Last year, in 2024, we burned yet another patch, which shifted grazing pressure to a new portion of the site and allowed the 2023 burned areas to start growing tall again. New management treatments in 2025 will continue to shift things around, while maintaining the same kind of habitat variety – just in different places.

If you missed it, I talked much more about habitat heterogeneity and why it’s important in this recent post. Our primary objective for the Platte River Prairies is to sustain high ecological resilience, which relies heavily upon species diversity (animals, plants, and more). We’re working under the assumption that providing a constantly-shifting mosaic of habitat types is the best way to support that species diversity.

There’s a lot of science that backs up that shifting mosaic assumption, but we try to test it whenever we can. Plant diversity has been very stable over the last 20 years or so on the sites I’m able to monitor closely. Habitat use by wildlife, including insects, is harder to quantify, but what we’ve seen has been positive. Birds species appear in different places each year, but all the species we’d expect to see always show up. Similarly, regal fritillary butterflies and other insect species seem to be doing well, but follow their favorite habitat conditions around the site. The plains pocket mouse – a species of concern in this part of the world – maintains surprisingly consistent populations, regardless of our management actions.

We’re always looking for researchers who’d like to help us look more closely at any aspect of the system – let me know if you’re interested! In the meantime, we’ll keep experimenting and learning the best we can.